Tag: Sean Bell

  • But that’s my car!

    A witness at the trial of the officers who shot Sean Bell testified today. She was a topless dancer at the club. Leaving aside all the real issues, I noticed something most people probably missed from her testimony: this woman is no stranger to crime scenes.

    Put yourself in her shoes: You’ve just had a long night dancing, you’re leaving, you’re walking to your car when suddenly you see a man jump out of car and start shooting at another car. You dive behind some bushes, hear 50 shots in total, cars running into things, and no doubt there’s some screaming and yelling.

    What would you do? Probably not what Ms. Payne did. According to the Times:

    After two or three minutes, she ran back to her car so she could move it before the police arrived, but she was too late, arriving to see paramedics pulling bodies from Mr. Bell’s car.

    She’s right, too. If your car is on the wrong side when the crime-scene tape goes up, it’s going to be a long time before you get to move those wheels. If your car happens to have a bullet in it, it’s even worse.

    Such is one of the many petty frustrations of living in a high-crime neighborhood.

  • Sean Bell shooting trial to stay in Queens

    The latest delay in the trial of police officers for killing Sean Bell comes from defense lawyers. They wanted the trial moved out of Queens. This motion was denied.

    I don’t really have a position on the trial location. But this is still a big decision. It’s not going to be easy to convict the officers (and for good reason), but there was no chance of conviction if the venue was moved outside of the city. It’s not the officers can’t get a fair trial in Queens. It’s simply that city juries, on average, are much less pro-police than suburban juries.

    The officers who beat Rodney King would not have been acquitted if their trial hadn’t been moved to conservative (and much more white) Simi Vally. The killer of police officer Kevon Gavin would have been convicted had his trial not been in Baltimore City. Justified or not, city folk, particularly African-American city folk, are less likely to trust police. In a police-related trial, jury bias–both pro- and anti-police–can outweigh the facts.

    In the case of Sean Bell, conviction is still unlikely. Mistakes are usually not crimes, especially for police officers.